The Smartest Kids In the World
and How They Got That Way
By Amanda Ripley
Summary of the
Appendix section
A good school for one
kid would be a horrible school for another kid, but that notwithstanding there
are some questions you can/should ask and things to look for when you visit
1.
Watch The
students
a.
Ignore the
open house
b.
Ignore the
spending per student (after a min. base level)
c.
Ignore
class size (except at the youngest ages)
d.
Teacher
quality trumps $/S, and class size
e.
Standardized
Test Data – better, but how did the test, what did they test?
f.
Watch for
what the school adds after the parent effect
2.
Observing guidelines
a.
Spend 20
min. watching a class in session
b.
Ignore the
bulletin boards, walls, displays etc.
c.
Don’t look
out for precision and order since chaotic rooms & activities may be very
productive and rigorous
d.
Watch the
students
i.
Are they
interested?
ii.
A couple
of bored kids is normal/ok, but 8-10 is too much
iii.
Are they
all working
e.
The
Class/The Teaching
i.
Rigorous
learning looks rigorous (effortful)
ii.
If the
kids zip through papers, that’s not learning
iii.
Kids
should be working near the top of their ability
iv.
Not using
time to line up, get ready, prepare etc.
v.
There
should be a sense of urgency you can feel in the room
f.
Teachers:
i.
Don’t
study the teacher – they vary too much and you can’t choose them
ii.
More
important is what the kids say after a year with a teacher than any observation
you can do
iii.
If the
kids focus too much on a visitor, it may mean they’re bored and looking for a
distraction
iv.
Boredom
should be the exception – not the rule
3.
Talk To
Students:
a.
Don’t ask,
“Do you like your school?” – it’s like asking an adult, at work, “Do you like
your boss?”
b.
Ask
specific questions:
c.
What are you doing right now?
d.
Why are you doing this? (this is a tough one: so, teachers need to
point out the purpose more often
e.
Tripod Survey: found that student answers to questions were more predictive of future
test scores than trained observers. They
asked 36 questions some of which A Ripley reproduces
i.
Do you learn a lot in this class every day?
ii.
Do students behave in the way that the teacher
wants?
iii.
Does this class stay busy and not waste time?
iv.
If you don’t understand something what do you
do?
1.
In rigorous classrooms students know the answer
– asks a peer and/or the teacher
4.
Ask Parents:
a.
Good
Question:
i.
Every
school has its weaknesses. What is this schools’ weakness?
b.
Warnings:
i.
If parents
are involved mostly in fund-raising and bake sales and PTA, run.
c.
Big
Impacts:
i.
Reading to
your kids (6 days/week)
ii.
Letting
them see you read
iii.
Acting
like a school coach to older kids: push, encourage, help them be resilient
after failure
iv.
Let them
fail and get back up again
v.
Ask “How
was your day?”
vi.
Ask &
Talk about current events & world events
vii.
Ignore the
“shiny” stuff: w/b and bb is fine for top quality edu.
5.
Smartest
Countries
a.
Prioritize
equity –more resources for students who need it most
b.
Teacher
pay (long term quality driver)
6.
Ask The
Principal Tough Questions:
a.
How do you
choose your teachers?
b.
How do you
help your teachers get better?
c.
Can you
choose which teachers to interview and hire?
d.
Do you
watch teachers do a sample lesson before hiring?
7.
Professional
Development
a.
Should be
customized to each teachers’ strengths and weaknesses, as opposed to huge
lectures to a mass of teachers
b.
Ts need to
watch each other teach.
c.
Ts need time
to plan and discuss ideas about what/how to do in the classroom
d.
Ts need
actionable feedback
8.
Success
Academy Schools
a.
Ss read in
class for 1 hr/day
b.
Ss write
in class for 1 hr/day
c.
They
always take recess
d.
Do arts
e.
Learn chess
f.
Have their
Ts over-estimate what their kids can do
g.
Ban baby-talk
h.
Parents
asked to read to their kids 6 nights/week
i.
Parents
asked to help/push their kids to get ready for colleg.