Rosalind and maybe Miranda have failed to learn during their critical periods. There are critical periods during which the brain is especially ready to learn certain things. e.g. how to print, how to spell, how to read, how to count forwards and backwards. If humans do not learn the special skills during the special critical periods then, they will have an extremely difficult time or perhaps even NEVER learn the skills they missed to a normatively typical level. If they begin 2 years later, then can not catch up in 2 years. It is not a delay. It is a critical window during which learning is much much faster. After that critical window, then learning is much much slower. So, it will take much longer to catch up. So, if you miss two years it might take 4 years to catch up. Let's look at an example. Sally does not begin to learn here ABCs until age 6. She missed her critical period at 3-4 years old. It should take only 1 year to learn to recognize and write the ABCs. Now she's 6. If she begins to study hard she can not learn in 1 year like her 3-year-old self could have. It might take her 2-3 years and she might never become good at it.
Rosalind is perhaps missing or has missed:
- letter formation -printing
- number formation - writing
- reading
- writing short, simple sentences. "This is Charlie. See Charlie sit. "
- spelling
- subtraction
- other 8-year-old math skills
Miranda
- spelling
- vocabulary (normally acquired via daily reading in school)
Our girls are like girls in Pakistan denied education.
Our girls have fun and enjoy lots of snacks, nature and eating and various media and art. The focus of the moms has been on self-expression, freedom and socialization.
Our girls have cognitive deficits because of missed critical periods because of their lack of education. Why lack of education? Veronica was traumatized by her father. He, himself was the child of an alcoholic mother and suffered a lack of parenting. He developed anxiety and OCD and this affected his parenting (lack of parenting). He only knew strict, Norman Rockwell style education and lifestyle. He only wanted that as a compensation for his lack of parenting. Her mother was traumatized by interment and over-compensated for rejection by being an extraordinarily "good" citizen. Super reliable, super worker, super normal. super trustworthy and super above suspicion. Never "inscrutable" This is the legacy of uber-structural racism enacted in the internment camp experience. So, her mother was a pressure cooker. Plus, for economic reasons. she worked full time and so was unavailable as a parent to her daughter. She expected her daughter to tow the line, to be good, to submit to authorities -in Veronica's case that meant school authorities. For this reason, plus the structural racism of schooling and the extra racism of small town, near northern Ontario she came to associate schooling, especially primary schooling with horror, boredom, oppression and lack of freedom. She came perhaps to vow to herself never to do that to her girls. Ironically, Veronica is often unavailable to her daughters because of her cognitive confusion and anxiety passed from her parents. This leads to massive amounts of time spent escaping in fantasy literature and TV and video. She also transmits high anxiety with writing the simplest documents even to people she knows but strangers too.
The program of socialization and art and nature in an unschooling context has led our girls to be uneducated and to miss critical periods for important skills. Can they ever catch up? Perhaps yes, perhaps no if they see other ways out - it will be much harder for them than for their schooled peers. It will take much longer. They are likely to suffer for the rest of their lives for the gaps they have and will probably never recover. They will likely suffer emotionally, in terms of confidence and certainty in their life chances and potential earnings and future happiness. That said, they will have had a relaxing, fun-filled, self-chosen, autonomous childhood for a few sweet years.Their nature skills and art skills and socialization skills will be superior.
They don't know:
- how to focus
- how to work hard
- how to do more than you are asked to do
- how to keep a tidy space or workspace or learning space
- what their range of interests really is (they've not been exposed to a range of areas they might have met in a school setting)
- grit, persistence
Their peers suffered too to be sure: boredom, wasted stuff, meaningless compliance to mindnumbing repetitive clerk like busy work, lack of freedom, lack of self-expression, oppression, bullying, modelling of other stupid, ignorant, kids with poor values.
Our parenting has been a massive failure. We have not educated our children. They are uneducated and probably damaged for life and limited for life because of it. They should be taken away and we should be fined and/or put in jail for neglect. How can there be no oversite of such massive and damaging neglect of children? Shouldn't parents have to register their plans with the Ministry of Ed? They have failed too.
No comments:
Post a Comment