So, I wondered how would that book's ideas compare with the Deep Work book by Cal Newport.
Structure for a piece.
- How they are, on the face of it, at odds with each other.
- How they are actually similar in important ways.
- the importance of being deliberate
- the fix is at the individual level (is that true?)
- Some third way, some middle way to reconcile them or improve upon both.
- Could have to do with the old guns kill people, people kill people style debate and how the effect of "deliberate work" and the effect of "slow professor" depend neither on who/how uses them and nor does it depend on the inherent features of either idea.
Idea Scraps:
- Newport's ostensible pragmatism re the moral value, rather the value neutral position, of deep work vs shallow rubs me the wrong way - there's something disingenuous about it.
Continued...Feb 24th...
I've read a summary article by Seeber and Berg prior to the publication of their book - I'm guessing that it fairly summarizes all of the issues that appear in the book but with fewer supports and fewer references.
While "Deep Work" seems to be about getting more work done more efficiently and making sure that more of the work is meaningful or 'deep', the "Slow Prof" book is about taking time to reflect, and be thoughtful.
While there are these seeming oppositions, both focus on being more deliberate in the academy and at work more generally (esp. deep work). The true differences lie in the fact that Slow Prof focuses on individual resistance to structural changes that prevent deep work. Whereas "Deep Work" focuses on the individual response to the distractions (esp. social media) inherent in modern life.
So, "Slow Prof" is much more structural and lefty in nature while "Deep Work" is much more 'how to I get along better in the current environment' and is, as such more right politically. Newport even touts, as a badge of honour, his pragmatic amoralism on questions of the ethical values of deep work. His book is about how to thrive in the current system, while Seeber and Berg's is more about resistance to the structural changes we see wrought large in the academy. This is a large difference and not to be made light of. I suspect they would not last long on a sofa at a party. Or, perhaps they'd get into a heated debate. I suspect Newport would have little time for them, and that Seeber and Berg would think him a stuffed shirt, conformist.
However, different their views are, ironically, they both recommend a more a similar prescription: deliberate, deep, slow, thoughtful work as the cure. Newport says it will let you do more of what you want to do. So do Seeber and Berg, how ever they see this as, primarily, a way to resist the corporatization of academic practice. This is interesting since they both come from the same context!
So, that blows my plan of emphasizing context as a "third way" doesn't it!

No comments:
Post a Comment